Illinois senator called the Little Giant who championed popular sovereignty, wrote the Kansas-Nebraska Act, beat Lincoln in 1858 and lost to him in 1860.
politicianslavery
He stood only about five feet four inches tall, yet Americans called Stephen A. Douglas the "Little Giant," and for most of the 1850s he was the most powerful man in the United States Senate. He had a booming voice, a barrel chest and seemingly endless energy, and he believed he had found the answer to the question tearing the country apart: let the people of each territory vote slavery up or down for themselves. Instead, his solution helped bring on the very crisis he spent his life trying to prevent.
Douglas was born on April 23, 1813, in Brandon, Vermont. His father, a doctor, died when Stephen was just two months old. As a teenager he was apprenticed to a cabinetmaker, but he wanted a life in law and politics. In 1833, at age twenty, he headed west to Illinois, then a fast-growing frontier state, where he taught school briefly and was admitted to the bar. His rise was astonishing. Within a decade he served as a state's attorney, a state legislator, Illinois secretary of state and a justice of the Illinois Supreme Court, which he joined at just 27. A devoted Democrat and admirer of Andrew Jackson, he believed passionately in the growth of the West: railroads, settlers and new states.
Douglas was elected to the U.S. House of Representatives in 1843 and to the Senate in 1847, where he cheered the expansion that followed the war with Mexico. In 1847 he married Martha Martin, whose father owned a large cotton plantation in Mississippi worked by enslaved people. After Martha died in 1853, Douglas managed the plantation on behalf of their two young sons and drew a share of its income, a fact his opponents used against him. In 1856 he married Adele Cutts, a grandniece of former first lady Dolley Madison.
The war with Mexico added huge new lands to the country, and by 1850 Congress was deadlocked over whether slavery could spread into them. Henry Clay bundled the issues into one giant bill, which collapsed that summer. Douglas, the rising star of a younger generation, split it into separate bills and assembled a different majority for each one. The result, the Compromise of 1850, admitted California as a free state, left slavery in the Utah and New Mexico territories to be decided later, and created a harsh new Fugitive Slave Act. The idea that settlers should decide had a name: popular sovereignty. Douglas loved it because it sounded democratic and took the explosive question out of Congress.
In January 1854, as chairman of the Senate Committee on Territories, Douglas introduced a bill to organize the vast land west of Iowa and Missouri. He wanted farmers to settle it, and he hoped for a transcontinental railroad running west from Chicago; historians still debate which motive mattered most. To win Southern votes, his final bill created two territories, Kansas and Nebraska, let their settlers decide about slavery, and repealed the 36°30′ line of the Missouri Compromise, which had kept slavery out of that region for 34 years. The Kansas-Nebraska Act passed in May 1854, and the North erupted in fury. Douglas later remarked that he could have traveled from Boston to Chicago by the light of his own burning effigies. Rival settlers rushed into Kansas, the territory slid into the violence known as Bleeding Kansas, and angry Northerners founded the Republican Party to stop slavery's spread.
Then Douglas did something brave that cost him dearly. In 1857 proslavery leaders in Kansas wrote the Lecompton Constitution and tried to bring Kansas into the Union as a slave state through a rigged vote that never let residents reject slavery outright. President James Buchanan, a fellow Democrat, backed it. Douglas denounced it as a fraud that betrayed popular sovereignty, breaking with his own president and with the Southern wing of his party. Kansas never entered under that constitution; it joined the Union as a free state in 1861.
The Supreme Court's Dred Scott decision of 1857 created another problem for Douglas: if Congress could not ban slavery in a territory, it seemed settlers could not either. In 1858, running for reelection to the Senate, he faced a Springfield lawyer named Abraham Lincoln, who opened his campaign with the "House Divided" speech. The two men met in seven famous debates across Illinois, from Ottawa on August 21 to Alton on October 15. At the second debate, in Freeport, Lincoln asked whether settlers could still keep slavery out. Douglas answered with what became known as the Freeport Doctrine: slavery could not last anywhere without local laws to protect it, so settlers could keep it out simply by refusing to pass them. Lincoln called slavery a moral wrong; Douglas insisted he did not care whether it was "voted down or voted up," only that the people decided. Both men made statements about race in those debates that are deeply offensive today, and Douglas in particular used openly racist appeals to attack Lincoln.
Here is where many people get Douglas's story wrong: he won that election. In 1858, state legislatures, not voters, chose U.S. senators. Republican candidates won slightly more votes statewide, but Democrats kept control of the Illinois legislature, which reelected Douglas 54 to 46 in January 1859. Still, the debates made Lincoln a national figure, and the Freeport Doctrine enraged Southern Democrats who wanted slavery protected in every territory.
That anger destroyed Douglas's dream of the presidency. In 1860 the Democratic Party split in two: Northern Democrats nominated Douglas, while Southern Democrats nominated John C. Breckinridge. Breaking with tradition, Douglas campaigned in person, even touring the South to warn that secession would be a disaster. In the election of 1860 he won nearly 30 percent of the popular vote, second only to Lincoln, but carried only Missouri and part of New Jersey, for just 12 electoral votes.
When Southern states began to secede, Douglas put the Union first. According to a popular story, he held his old rival's hat while Lincoln took the oath of office in March 1861, though accounts of the moment differ. After Confederate guns fired on Fort Sumter in April, he met with Lincoln and then traveled home to rally Northern Democrats behind the war. "There can be no neutrals in this war," he told a crowd in Chicago, "only patriots or traitors." Exhausted, he fell ill with typhoid fever and died in Chicago on June 3, 1861, at age 48.
Historians often see Douglas's career as a lesson in the limits of compromise. He sincerely believed that local democracy could settle anything and that popular sovereignty would keep the peace. But by treating slavery as a question of votes rather than of right and wrong, he reopened the conflict the Missouri Compromise had contained, and he helped split both his party and the nation. In his last weeks, though, he chose the Union over party. You can trace his clashes with Lincoln in the Slavery & Sectional Crisis journey and review them for the U.S. History final.