Loading...
Loading...
In 1857 the Supreme Court ruled 7 to 2 that Black Americans could not be citizens and that Congress could not ban slavery in the territories.
Where this fits on the timeline. On March 6, 1857, two days after James Buchanan became president, the Supreme Court answered a lawsuit that an enslaved man in St. Louis had started eleven years earlier. Dred Scott had asked a fairly narrow question: had living on free soil made him free? Chief Justice Roger B. Taney's answer went far beyond Scott. He ruled that Black Americans could not be citizens and that Congress had no power to ban slavery in any federal territory, which made the Missouri Compromise unconstitutional. It was only the second time the Court had struck down an act of Congress, 54 years after Marbury v. Madison, and instead of settling the slavery question it pushed the nation closer to war. It is a key case in the Landmark Supreme Court Cases journey.
A life on the move. Dred Scott was born into slavery in Virginia around 1799 and was taken to St. Louis, Missouri, by the Blow family who enslaved him. In 1833 he was sold to Dr. John Emerson, an army surgeon. Emerson took Scott with him to Fort Armstrong at Rock Island, Illinois, a free state, and in 1836 to Fort Snelling in the Wisconsin Territory, in what is now Minnesota, where the Missouri Compromise banned slavery.
A family. At Fort Snelling, Scott married Harriet Robinson, a young woman enslaved by the local Indian agent. The couple had two daughters, Eliza, born in 1838, and Lizzie, born in 1840. Emerson later brought the family back to Missouri.
"Once free, always free." After Emerson died in 1843, the Scotts were held by his widow, Irene Emerson. In 1846 Dred and Harriet each sued for their freedom in the St. Louis courts. Their case was strong: Missouri judges had long freed enslaved people who had been taken to live in free states or territories. The Scotts lost their first trial in 1847 on a technicality, because key testimony was ruled to be hearsay. At a second trial in 1850, a jury declared them free.
Missouri changes course. In 1852 the Missouri Supreme Court overturned the verdict and abandoned its own long-standing rule. Pointing to rising anger over slavery, one judge wrote that "times now are not as they were."
Into federal court. Scott's lawyers then turned to the federal courts, suing John F. A. Sanford of New York, Irene Emerson's brother, who was acting as the family's owner. A federal court can hear a lawsuit between citizens of different states, but only if both sides are citizens. The federal court in St. Louis ruled against Scott in 1854, and he appealed to the Supreme Court. A court reporter misspelled the defendant's name, so the case is known as Dred Scott v. Sandford.
Seven to two. The justices heard the case twice, in 1856, and announced their decision on March 6, 1857. Each of the nine justices wrote his own opinion, but seven ruled against Scott. The opinion of the Court was delivered by Chief Justice Roger B. Taney of Maryland, 79 years old, who had succeeded John Marshall in 1836.
Ruling one: no citizenship. Taney wrote that Black Americans, whether enslaved or free, were not and could never become citizens of the United States, so Scott had no right to sue in federal court. He claimed that at the nation's founding, Black people had been regarded as so inferior that "they had no rights which the white man was bound to respect."
Ruling two: no power to ban slavery in the territories. Taney could have stopped there. Instead he went on to declare that Congress had no power to ban slavery in the federal territories. Enslaved people were property, he argued, and the Fifth Amendment says no person may be deprived of "property, without due process of law." So the Missouri Compromise's ban on slavery north of 36°30′ had been unconstitutional all along, and Scott's years at Fort Snelling had not made him free.
Two dissents. Justices John McLean of Ohio and Benjamin Curtis of Massachusetts disagreed. Curtis showed that when the Constitution was ratified, free Black men could vote in five states, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, New York, New Jersey and North Carolina, so they had been part of the people who created it. Curtis resigned from the Court later in 1857, in part because of bitter disputes over the case.
A president's thumb on the scale. In his inaugural address on March 4, Buchanan told the nation that the question of slavery in the territories would be settled "speedily and finally" by the Supreme Court. Letters published long afterward show he already knew what was coming: he had privately urged Justice Robert Grier of Pennsylvania to join the five justices from slave states so the ruling would not look purely Southern. Historians widely view that private pressure from a president-elect on a sitting justice as improper.
The South cheered; the North seethed. Many Southern leaders celebrated, because slavery now appeared to have constitutional protection in every territory. Many Northerners were alarmed. The Republican Party's central goal, stopping slavery's spread into the territories, had just been declared unconstitutional, and Republicans charged that a "Slave Power" controlled both the president and the Court. Abraham Lincoln attacked the ruling, and in his "House Divided" speech of 1858 he warned that a future decision might forbid any state to keep slavery out. Frederick Douglass told an audience in May 1857 that despite the decision, "my hopes were never brighter than now," predicting it would awaken the nation's conscience.
A trap for Douglas. The ruling also caused problems for Senator Stephen A. Douglas. If Congress could not ban slavery in a territory, how could settlers vote it out under popular sovereignty? In his 1858 debates with Lincoln, Douglas offered the Freeport Doctrine: settlers could keep slavery out simply by refusing to pass local laws to protect it. That answer angered Southern Democrats and helped split the party before the election of 1860.
The Scotts go free. By then Irene Emerson had married Calvin Chaffee, an antislavery congressman from Massachusetts, who was embarrassed by the case. Ownership of the Scotts was transferred to Taylor Blow, a son of Dred's first enslaver, and on May 26, 1857, he freed them in a St. Louis court. Dred Scott worked as a hotel porter and died of tuberculosis on September 17, 1858, after about sixteen months of freedom. Harriet lived until 1876.
Overturned by war and amendment. No later Supreme Court ruling reversed Dred Scott; the Civil War and the Constitution did. The Thirteenth Amendment (1865) abolished slavery, and the Fourteenth Amendment (1868) declared that all persons born or naturalized in the United States are citizens, directly rejecting Taney's ruling on citizenship. Many legal scholars rank it among the Court's worst decisions. Follow the chain of events in the Slavery & Sectional Crisis journey and review it, alongside Marbury, for the U.S. History final.
The Missouri Compromise had already been repealed. The Kansas-Nebraska Act repealed the 36°30′ line in 1854. Three years later the Court ruled that the line had been unconstitutional all along, which also meant Congress could never pass another one like it.
Sandford is a misspelling. The defendant's real name was John F. A. Sanford. The official court report spelled it Sandford, and the case name kept the mistake.
The ruling was about territories and citizenship, not free states. Dred Scott did not legalize slavery in Illinois or other free states. Lincoln's fear was that a later ruling might go that far.
1. Why did Dred Scott argue that he was free? His enslaver had taken him to live in Illinois, a free state, and at Fort Snelling in the Wisconsin Territory, where the Missouri Compromise banned slavery.
2. What were the two most important rulings in Taney's opinion? That Black Americans could not be U.S. citizens and so could not sue in federal court, and that Congress had no power to ban slavery in the territories, which made the Missouri Compromise unconstitutional.
3. How did the Constitution later reverse the decision? The Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery in 1865, and the Fourteenth Amendment in 1868 made everyone born or naturalized in the United States a citizen.
Dred Scott and his wife, Harriet, sued for freedom in St. Louis in 1846, arguing that living in Illinois and at Fort Snelling in the Wisconsin Territory had made Dred free.
A Missouri jury freed the Scotts in 1850, but the Missouri Supreme Court reversed the verdict in 1852, and the case reached the U.S. Supreme Court as Dred Scott v. Sandford.
On March 6, 1857, the Court ruled 7 to 2 against Scott; Chief Justice Roger B. Taney wrote that Black Americans, enslaved or free, could not be U.S. citizens.
Taney also ruled that Congress could not ban slavery in the federal territories, declaring the Missouri Compromise unconstitutional; it was only the second time the Court had struck down an act of Congress, after Marbury v. Madison in 1803.
The decision outraged many Northerners, strengthened the Republican Party, and helped split the Democrats by undercutting Stephen A. Douglas's popular sovereignty.
The Scotts were freed by the Blow family in May 1857, and the Thirteenth and Fourteenth Amendments later abolished slavery and overturned the ruling on citizenship.
CrashCourse · 14:16