Loading...
Loading...
Accepting the Illinois Republican Senate nomination on June 16, 1858, Lincoln warned that the nation could not endure "permanently half slave and half free."
Where this fits on the timeline. On the evening of June 16, 1858, a 49-year-old Springfield lawyer stood in the Hall of Representatives of the Illinois State Capitol and gave the delegates of the state Republican convention a warning they would not forget: "A house divided against itself cannot stand." The speaker was Abraham Lincoln, and he was opening his campaign against Senator Stephen A. Douglas. The speech came four years after the Kansas-Nebraska Act and one year after the Dred Scott decision, and it set the terms for the most famous debates in American political history.
An unusual nomination. In 1858, U.S. senators were chosen by state legislatures, not by voters, so parties usually did not name a Senate candidate in advance. But Illinois Republicans were worried. Some Eastern Republicans admired Douglas for fighting the proslavery Lecompton Constitution in Kansas and hoped to win him over. To head that off, the convention declared Lincoln its "first and only choice" for Douglas's Senate seat. The delegates chose him at about five in the afternoon, broke for dinner, and returned at eight to hear him speak.
A carefully prepared speech. Lincoln worked on the speech for weeks. According to later recollections, when he read the opening to a group of friends, most of them thought it too radical and urged him to soften it. He kept it.
A saying everyone knew. Lincoln opened with words of Jesus found in the Gospels of Mark and Matthew, familiar to nearly every American of his day. Then he made his central claim: "I believe this government cannot endure, permanently half slave and half free." He did not expect the Union to break apart, he said, but he did expect that "it will become all one thing, or all the other." Either opponents of slavery would stop its spread and place it where the public could rest in the belief that it was "in the course of ultimate extinction," or its supporters would push it forward until it was lawful in every state, "old as well as new, North as well as South."
A charge of conspiracy. Most of the speech argued that recent events looked like a plan. The Kansas-Nebraska Act had opened free territory to slavery; the Dred Scott decision said Congress could not ban slavery in any territory; and Douglas's claim that he did not care whether slavery was voted up or down was teaching the public not to care either. Lincoln compared the pattern to the frame of a house built by four workmen, "Stephen, Franklin, Roger and James," meaning Douglas, President Franklin Pierce, Chief Justice Roger Taney and President James Buchanan. The pieces fit together too well, he suggested, to be an accident. He warned that one more Supreme Court ruling could declare that no state could keep slavery out, so that Illinois might wake up to find itself a slave state.
Seven debates. The speech framed the Lincoln-Douglas debates, seven face-to-face meetings in Illinois towns from August 21 to October 15, 1858. Douglas used the House Divided speech against Lincoln, charging that it invited war between the sections and favored racial equality. Lincoln answered that he had no plan to interfere with slavery in the states where it already existed; his goal was to stop it from spreading. Both men made statements about race in those debates that are offensive today, and Lincoln, though he called slavery a moral wrong, was not an abolitionist in the mold of William Lloyd Garrison.
Lincoln lost, then won. Republican candidates won slightly more votes statewide, but Democrats kept control of the Illinois legislature, which reelected Douglas 54 to 46 in January 1859. Still, newspapers across the country printed the debates, and Lincoln became a national figure. Southern critics pointed to the House Divided speech as proof that he was a dangerous radical. Two years later he won the Republican nomination and the election of 1860.
A prediction that came true. Lincoln said the house would "cease to be divided," and it did, though at a cost no one in that hall imagined. Within three years of the speech the Civil War had begun, and in 1863 Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation turned the war into a fight to end slavery. The speech is a key primary source because it explains, in Lincoln's own words, why Republicans saw slavery's expansion as a threat to the whole nation. Read it alongside the Slavery & Sectional Crisis journey and review it for the U.S. History final.
It was a Senate speech, not a presidential one. Lincoln gave the House Divided speech in 1858 while running for the U.S. Senate, two years before he ran for president. He lost that Senate race.
Lincoln did not invent the phrase. "A house divided against itself cannot stand" comes from the Bible, and other Americans had used similar images before. Lincoln's contribution was applying it to slavery so clearly.
He did not call for ending slavery immediately. Lincoln predicted the nation would become all free or all slave, and he wanted slavery put on the road to "ultimate extinction," but in 1858 he promised not to interfere with slavery where it already existed.
1. What office was Lincoln seeking when he gave the speech? A U.S. Senate seat from Illinois, held by Stephen A. Douglas, in 1858.
2. What did Lincoln mean by "half slave and half free"? That the nation could not go on forever with slavery legal in some states and banned in others; eventually it would become all one or all the other.
3. Who were "Stephen, Franklin, Roger and James"? Stephen Douglas, Franklin Pierce, Roger Taney and James Buchanan, whom Lincoln accused of acting together, knowingly or not, to spread slavery.
Lincoln gave the speech on June 16, 1858, in the Illinois State Capitol in Springfield after the state Republican convention named him its "first and only choice" for the U.S. Senate.
Using a saying of Jesus from the Gospels, he warned that "a house divided against itself cannot stand" and that the government could not endure "permanently half slave and half free."
He predicted the nation would become "all one thing, or all the other," with slavery either put on a course to "ultimate extinction" or made lawful everywhere.
He argued that Douglas, Pierce, Taney and Buchanan ("Stephen, Franklin, Roger and James") had acted together to spread slavery through the Kansas-Nebraska Act and Dred Scott.
The speech framed the seven Lincoln-Douglas debates of 1858; Lincoln lost the Senate seat when the legislature reelected Douglas 54 to 46.
The race made Lincoln a national figure and helped him win the Republican nomination and the presidency in 1860.