Loading...
Loading...
In 1820 Congress admitted Missouri as a slave state and Maine as a free one and drew the 36°30′ line, holding off the fight over slavery's spread for 34 years.
Where this fits on the timeline. In February 1819, what should have been a routine request turned into the most dangerous argument the young republic had faced. Missouri wanted to join the Union, and a New York congressman proposed a condition: no more slavery there. The fight that followed showed that the bargains over slavery written into the Constitution in 1787 had only postponed the question. The deal Congress struck in 1820 kept the peace for 34 years, and it opens the story told in the Slavery & Sectional Crisis journey.
Missouri was the next big piece of the Louisiana Purchase to seek statehood. The United States had bought the vast Louisiana Territory from France in 1803, and the state of Louisiana had joined the Union in 1812. Settlers poured into Missouri Territory from Kentucky, Tennessee and Virginia, and many brought enslaved people with them; by the 1820 census more than 10,000 of Missouri's residents were enslaved. Its leaders expected to enter the Union with slavery legal, just as other Southern states had.
A balance of eleven and eleven. When Alabama was admitted in December 1819, the Union had 22 states: 11 free and 11 slave. Because every state has two senators, that meant an exact tie in the Senate, 22 to 22. The North already held a majority in the House, where seats follow population, and the North was growing faster. For Southern leaders, the even Senate was their protection. Whichever way Missouri went would break the tie.
One amendment set off a firestorm. On February 13, 1819, Representative James Tallmadge Jr. of New York proposed two conditions for Missouri statehood: no more enslaved people could be brought into the state, and children born to enslaved parents after statehood would be freed at age 25. It was a plan for slow, gradual emancipation, much like the ones Northern states had used to end slavery within their own borders. The House, where the North had more seats, passed it in votes that split almost exactly along sectional lines. The Senate voted it down. Congress went home with Missouri still waiting, and the argument spread to newspapers, state legislatures and public meetings across the country.
Why the South reacted so strongly. Southern leaders argued that Congress had no power to put conditions on a new state that the original thirteen had never faced. They also saw a larger threat: if Congress could ban slavery in Missouri, it could ban slavery anywhere in the West, and the slaveholding states would slowly be outnumbered. Northern critics answered that the Constitution gave Congress power over the territories and over admitting new states, and that spreading slavery into new land betrayed the nation's founding ideals.
Maine provided the way out. For years the District of Maine, then part of Massachusetts, had wanted to become a state of its own. In early 1820 the Senate tied the two questions together: Maine would enter as a free state and Missouri as a slave state, keeping the Senate balanced at 12 states to 12.
A line across the map. Senator Jesse B. Thomas of Illinois added the piece that made the deal famous. In the rest of the Louisiana Purchase, slavery would be "forever prohibited" north of latitude 36°30′, roughly Missouri's southern border, with Missouri itself as the one exception. Land south of the line, including what became Arkansas, stayed open to slavery.
Clay counts the votes. The Speaker of the House, Henry Clay of Kentucky, did not invent the line, but he steered the separate pieces through a deeply divided House, persuading just enough Northerners to accept Missouri with slavery and just enough Southerners to accept the line. President James Monroe signed the law on March 6, 1820, and Maine became the 23rd state on March 15.
Missouri nearly wrecked the deal. Missouri's new state constitution, written in 1820, protected slavery and also told the legislature to keep free Black people from moving into the state. Many Northerners objected that free Black people were citizens in several states, and the Constitution says citizens of each state are entitled to the "privileges and immunities" of citizens in the others. In March 1821 Clay brokered a second compromise: Missouri could join only if it promised the clause would never be used to deny any citizen's rights. The promise was vague, and Missouri later passed laws restricting free Black people anyway, but on August 10, 1821, Missouri became the 24th state.
The founders heard a warning. Retired president Thomas Jefferson wrote in April 1820 that the Missouri question, "like a fire bell in the night, awakened and filled me with terror." He feared that a line dividing the country by geography and by its views on slavery would never be erased. Secretary of State John Quincy Adams wrote in his diary that the crisis was "a title page to a great tragic volume." Both men saw that the compromise had quieted the argument without settling it.
The line held for a generation, then fell twice. The line did not cover the huge territory won from Mexico in 1848, so Congress had to bargain all over again in the Compromise of 1850. In 1854 the Kansas-Nebraska Act, pushed by Senator Stephen A. Douglas, repealed the 36°30′ line and let settlers vote on slavery for themselves, setting off violence in Kansas. Then in 1857 the Supreme Court's Dred Scott decision ruled that Congress had never had the power to ban slavery in the territories, declaring the Missouri Compromise unconstitutional. It was only the second time the Court had struck down an act of Congress, after Marbury v. Madison in 1803. Four years later the country was at war.
Compromise bought time, not a solution. The Missouri Compromise shows a pattern that repeats all the way to the Civil War: each time the country grew, the question of slavery came back, and each settlement depended on keeping free and slave states in balance. It also taught Americans to picture the nation as two sections with a line on the map between them. Expect it on the U.S. History final, usually paired with the Compromise of 1850 and the Kansas-Nebraska Act.
Missouri was the slave state; Maine was the free state. Students sometimes flip them. Remember that Missouri's request started the fight over slavery, and Maine was added to balance it.
Henry Clay did not draw the 36°30′ line. Clay earned his nickname "the Great Compromiser" by managing the votes in 1820 and brokering the second compromise in 1821, but the line itself came from Senator Jesse Thomas of Illinois.
Repealed is not the same as ruled unconstitutional. Congress repealed the line in the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854; three years later the Supreme Court said in Dred Scott that it had been unconstitutional all along. Both ended it, in different ways.
1. Why did Missouri's request for statehood threaten the balance in Congress? In 1819 there were 11 free and 11 slave states, so the Senate was evenly split; admitting Missouri either way would break the tie.
2. What did the 36°30′ line do? It banned slavery in the rest of the Louisiana Purchase north of that latitude, except in Missouri itself, while leaving land to the south open to slavery.
3. How did the Missouri Compromise come to an end? The Kansas-Nebraska Act repealed it in 1854, and the Dred Scott decision of 1857 declared that Congress had never had the power to pass it.
When Missouri asked to join the Union in 1819, there were 11 free and 11 slave states, so its admission either way would break the tie in the Senate.
The Tallmadge Amendment, which would have gradually ended slavery in Missouri, passed the House but failed in the Senate and set off a national crisis.
The compromise signed on March 6, 1820, admitted Maine as a free state and Missouri as a slave state, keeping the Senate balanced at 12 states to 12.
Slavery was banned in the rest of the Louisiana Purchase north of 36°30′ latitude, except in Missouri; Senator Jesse Thomas proposed the line and Speaker Henry Clay pushed the deal through the House.
Thomas Jefferson called the crisis "a fire bell in the night," warning that a line dividing the nation over slavery might one day break it apart.
The Kansas-Nebraska Act repealed the line in 1854, and the Supreme Court declared it unconstitutional in the Dred Scott decision of 1857.