Loading...
Loading...
In May 1856 John Brown and seven followers killed five proslavery settlers along Pottawatomie Creek, turning Bleeding Kansas into guerrilla war.
Where this fits on the timeline. On the night of May 24, 1856, three days after proslavery forces wrecked the free-state town of Lawrence in the Sack of Lawrence, John Brown led a small party to cabins along Pottawatomie Creek in eastern Kansas Territory and killed five proslavery settlers. The killings turned the struggle over Kansas, opened two years earlier by the Kansas-Nebraska Act, into a summer of guerrilla war. They also made Brown known across the country three years before his raid on Harpers Ferry, and they remain the hardest part of his story to explain.
A family on the free-state side. Several of Brown's sons moved to Kansas in 1855 to farm near Pottawatomie Creek and support the free-state cause. When they wrote home asking for weapons to defend themselves, their father, then 55 years old, came himself in the fall of 1855 with a wagon of guns. Brown had spent decades as an abolitionist and had come to believe that slavery was a sin against God that words alone would never end.
Tension along the creek. In April 1856 a proslavery territorial court met at Dutch Henry's Crossing on Pottawatomie Creek, and some local proslavery men, including members of the Doyle family, took part in it. Free-state settlers saw the court as a threat aimed at them, and rumors spread that proslavery men planned to drive free-state families out of the area.
News from Lawrence and Washington. An antislavery militia company that included Brown and his sons had marched toward Lawrence to defend it but learned they were too late. While camped, they also heard that Senator Charles Sumner had been beaten in the Senate chamber for his speech against proslavery violence in Kansas. Brown decided to strike back.
Who went. Brown's party had eight men: Brown; four of his sons, Frederick, Owen, Salmon and Oliver; his son-in-law Henry Thompson; and two other settlers, Theodore Weiner and James Townsley, who drove the wagon.
What happened. After dark the group went to three cabins near Dutch Henry's Crossing. They took James Doyle and his two adult sons, William and Drury, from their home, sparing a 16-year-old son after his mother pleaded for him. They then took Allen Wilkinson, a member of the proslavery territorial legislature, and finally William Sherman. All five men were killed with swords near their homes in the early hours of May 25. The Doyles were a poor family from Tennessee who did not own enslaved people; they had sided with the proslavery party after arriving in Kansas.
Revenge, fear and a holy war. Brown justified the killings in religious and moral terms, presenting them as a blow against men who threatened free-state families. Historians point to several motives: retaliation for Lawrence and for the attack on Sumner, a plan to terrify proslavery settlers into leaving the creek, and Brown's anger that free-state leaders had let Lawrence be sacked without a fight. Brown was careful never to say publicly exactly what he had done himself, and for years many Northern admirers refused to believe he was responsible. A congressional committee investigating the Kansas troubles identified him as the leader, and members of his party later described the night in detail.
Retaliation answered retaliation. Proslavery forces hunted Brown, and federal troops arrested two of his sons, John Jr. and Jason, who had not taken part. On June 2, 1856, Brown's men captured a proslavery militia leader, Henry Clay Pate, at the Battle of Black Jack. On August 30, a proslavery force attacked the free-state town of Osawatomie; Brown's son Frederick was killed that morning, and much of the town was burned. The fight gave Brown his famous nickname, "Osawatomie Brown." By one count, about thirty people died in the raids and battles of that summer. Order returned only after a new territorial governor, John Geary, arrived in September 1856 and used federal troops to keep the peace.
Hero, terrorist or both? For proslavery Southerners, Pottawatomie proved that abolitionists were murderers. Many Northerners who later honored Brown as a martyr after Harpers Ferry downplayed the Kansas killings or did not know the full story. The violence also marked how far some opponents of slavery had moved from the path of moral persuasion and nonviolence urged for decades by William Lloyd Garrison. Historians still disagree about how to judge Brown, but nearly all agree that the killing of unarmed men taken from their families at night cannot be separated from his later fame. Trace the escalating violence in the Slavery & Sectional Crisis journey and review it for the U.S. History final.
Pottawatomie is not Osawatomie. Pottawatomie Creek is where Brown's party killed five proslavery men in May 1856. Osawatomie is the nearby town where Brown fought a proslavery force in August 1856, the source of his nickname "Osawatomie Brown."
John Brown, not John Brown Jr. Brown's eldest son, John Jr., commanded the militia company but did not take part in the killings. He was arrested anyway, along with his brother Jason.
It was not the only killing of five in Kansas. On May 19, 1858, proslavery men captured eleven free-state men near the Marais des Cygnes River and shot them, killing five. Violence came from both sides in Bleeding Kansas.
1. What events in May 1856 led John Brown to act? The proslavery Sack of Lawrence on May 21 and the caning of Senator Charles Sumner on May 22.
2. Who were the victims? Five proslavery settlers: James Doyle and his sons William and Drury, Allen Wilkinson and William Sherman.
3. What were the consequences of the killings? They set off a summer of retaliatory raids and battles, including Black Jack and Osawatomie, and made Brown nationally famous.
On the night of May 24, 1856, John Brown led a party of eight, including four of his sons and his son-in-law, to cabins along Pottawatomie Creek in Kansas Territory.
They killed five proslavery settlers: James Doyle and his sons William and Drury, Allen Wilkinson and William Sherman.
Brown acted three days after the Sack of Lawrence and right after news that Senator Charles Sumner had been beaten in the Senate.
Brown justified the killings in religious and moral terms but never publicly described his own role; a congressional committee named him the leader.
Retaliation followed at the Battle of Black Jack and at Osawatomie, where Brown's son Frederick was killed and Brown earned the nickname "Osawatomie Brown."
The killings made Brown nationally known and remain the most debated part of his legacy three years before Harpers Ferry.