Loading...
Loading...
In 1803 Chief Justice John Marshall turned a fight over one undelivered commission into judicial review: the Court's power to strike down unconstitutional laws.
Where this fits on the timeline. The Constitution of 1787 created a Supreme Court, but it never said in so many words that judges could cancel a law passed by Congress. Sixteen years later, a bitter fight between the country's first two political parties handed Chief Justice John Marshall the chance to settle the question. His opinion in Marbury v. Madison, announced on February 24, 1803, established judicial review, which is why it comes first in the Landmark Supreme Court Cases journey.
A party losing power, and racing the clock. In the election of 1800, Thomas Jefferson and his Democratic-Republicans defeated President John Adams and the Federalists. Before Jefferson took office on March 4, 1801, the outgoing Federalist Congress created dozens of new judicial posts, and Adams hurried to fill them with loyal Federalists. On March 2 he nominated 42 justices of the peace for the District of Columbia, and the Senate confirmed them the next day, Adams's last full day in office. Jeffersonians mocked the last-minute appointees as "midnight judges."
The commissions that never arrived. A commission is the official document that gives a person an appointed office. Adams's secretary of state was John Marshall, who had already been confirmed as the new Chief Justice in January 1801 and was doing both jobs at once. Marshall's office signed and sealed the commissions, but in the final rush some were never delivered. When Jefferson took over, he ordered his new secretary of state, James Madison, to hold them back.
One appointee went straight to the top. William Marbury, a wealthy Federalist businessman, was one of the men left without his commission. In December 1801 he asked the Supreme Court for a writ of mandamus, a court order commanding an official to perform a legal duty, in this case ordering Madison to hand over the commission. Marbury filed directly in the Supreme Court because Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789 appeared to allow it.
Congress shuts the Court for a year. Jefferson's party struck back at the Federalist judges. In 1802 Congress repealed the law that had created the new circuit judgeships and rearranged the Court's calendar so that it did not meet at all that year. When the justices finally took up the case in February 1803, Madison did not even send a lawyer to defend him.
A no-win situation. If the Court ordered Madison to deliver the commission, Jefferson would probably ignore the order, and the Court, which has no army and no money of its own, would look powerless. If the Court simply backed down, it would look as if it were bowing to Jefferson. Marshall found a third path.
Three questions, one surprise. Writing for a unanimous Court, Marshall asked three questions. Did Marbury have a right to his commission? Yes; the appointment was complete once the commission was signed and sealed. Did the law offer him a remedy? Yes; withholding the commission violated his rights. Could the Supreme Court provide that remedy? No. Article III of the Constitution lists the few kinds of cases the Supreme Court may hear first, its original jurisdiction, and a suit like Marbury's is not among them. Marshall read Section 13 as trying to add to that list, and Congress cannot change the Constitution by passing an ordinary law. That part of the act was therefore void, and the Court could not help Marbury. Legal scholars still argue over whether Section 13 really had to be read that way, or whether Marshall chose that reading to reach the result he wanted.
The power hidden inside a loss. Marshall's most famous sentence explained why the Court could do this: "It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is." When a law conflicts with the Constitution, a judge must follow the Constitution, because it is the supreme law of the land. By giving up a small power, issuing one order, Marshall claimed a much larger one: the power to decide whether acts of Congress are constitutional. Jefferson disliked Marshall's lecture about his duty to deliver the commissions, but there was nothing for him to defy, since the ruling went his way.
Marshall did not invent judicial review from nothing. Colonial and state courts had sometimes refused to enforce laws that clashed with their charters or constitutions. In Federalist No. 78, Alexander Hamilton had argued that federal judges would have a duty to treat unconstitutional laws as void. What Marshall did was turn that argument into a binding decision of the nation's highest court.
A power used rarely at first. The Court did not strike down another act of Congress for 54 years, until the Dred Scott decision of 1857 declared the Missouri Compromise unconstitutional, one of the most disastrous rulings in its history. Marshall served as Chief Justice for 34 years, until his death in 1835, longer than anyone else has held the job, and his decisions steadily strengthened the national government. William Marbury never got his job.
Why it matters today. Judicial review is the courts' main tool in the system of checks and balances: Congress writes laws and the president enforces them, but the courts can rule that a law or action goes beyond what the Constitution allows. Landmark rulings such as Brown v. Board of Education (1954), which struck down school segregation laws, rest on the principle Marshall announced. It is one of the cases you are most likely to see on the Civics final.
Madison was the defendant, not the judge. The "Madison" in the name is James Madison, Jefferson's secretary of state, who was sued for withholding the commission. The opinion was written by Chief Justice John Marshall.
Marbury lost. The Court agreed Marbury deserved his commission but ruled it had no power to order its delivery, so he never received it. The real winner, in the long run, was the Court itself.
Judicial review is not spelled out in the Constitution. No clause says the Supreme Court may strike down laws. The power comes from Marshall's reasoning in this case, built on the Constitution's statement that it is "the supreme Law of the Land."
1. What is judicial review? It is the power of courts to decide whether a law or government action violates the Constitution, and to refuse to enforce it if it does.
2. Which law did the Court strike down in Marbury v. Madison? Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789, because the Court ruled it gave the Supreme Court original jurisdiction that the Constitution does not allow.
3. Why is Marshall's decision often called clever? By ruling against Marbury he avoided giving an order Jefferson could ignore, while still claiming for the Court the far greater power to declare laws unconstitutional.
Marbury v. Madison, decided on February 24, 1803, established judicial review, the power of courts to declare laws unconstitutional.
The case began when President John Adams's last-minute appointments left William Marbury's commission as a justice of the peace undelivered, and Jefferson's secretary of state, James Madison, refused to hand it over.
Chief Justice John Marshall ruled that Marbury had a right to his commission but that the Supreme Court had no power to order its delivery.
The Court struck down Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789 because it expanded the Court's original jurisdiction beyond what Article III of the Constitution allows.
Marshall wrote that it is "emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is," making the courts a real check on Congress and the president.
The Court did not strike down another act of Congress until the Dred Scott decision of 1857, but judicial review now underlies nearly every landmark constitutional case.